Articles
Scientific Literacy
Beyond
Reason: Science In The Mass Media
"I am outraged by the pseudoscience, antiscience, and plain lack
of common sense that I see on television, read in books, magazines and
tabloids, and hear on the radio. All of these distort, confuse, and plain
misinform about science, how science is done, and who practices science.
Much of the media, especially television, preys on the superstitions and
fears of unknowledgeable citizens who live in a civilization acutely dependent
on science and on scientific reasoning, simply to sell their products.
Americans deserve much, much better! That is what I want to show in this
chapter."
How
Scientific Illiteracy Hobbles Society
"In an oft-told variation of the Hindu myth of cosmology, a young
boy asks his father what holds up the Earth. Amused, the father assures
his son that the world rests on the back of a very large turtle. "But
what holds up the turtle?" the boy asks. After brief reflection,
the father says, "A huge elephant." "But," the boy
continues, "what is under the elephant?" Sensing that he is
rapidly losing control of the conversation, the father finally exclaims,
"Son, it's elephants all the way down from there!" As one who
interacts frequently with the public, I often hear similarly disconcerting
explanations about the "cosmology" of the modern world. If one
asks a new owner how their home computer works, one is likely to hear:
"You plug it in, push the "on" button...and it's all microchips
from there on down."
The Decline
Of Reason?
"The National Science Board and the National Science Foundation issued
a survey of 2006 randomly selected American adults (National Science Board,
1996). The survey had 10 questions, eight of which were simple true-false
or multiple-choice questions. Seventy-five percent of those adults failed
the quiz. These were pretty easy questions. The true scientific illiteracy
rate of Americans may well be more like 95% (Sagan, 1996). Sad, and of
major consequence to our country and to us as individuals. The Oakland
Tribune simultaneously reported that high tech and biotechnology companies
were leaving Silicon Valley and California because they could not find
a properly educated work force, one that is capable of understanding the
scientific thought processes as well as general knowledge. California
has failed its kids, and they will suffer as adults! But California is
not alone. Indeed scientific illiteracy plagues the United States and
the rest of the world. People will vote or decide about critical scientific
issues that affect each and every one of us without any understanding
of science. That is scary! Our own futures are at risk."
An
Introduction To Science: Scientific Thinking And The Scientific Method
"To succeed in this general science course you should be familiar
with a few of the concepts regarding the definition of science, scientific
thinking, and the methods of science. Most textbooks do an inadequate
job of this
task, so this essay provides that information.
Jonathan
Cole Discusses Scientific Illiteracy
The
Nature of Evidence
"We write about science because we love science and want to communicate
our fascination with the natural world. And we write about science and
technology because we believe that the more people know and understand,
the better informed public opinion will be. Of course, we must also cover
the harms or the risks that some technologies pose. We do this not because
we question the overall value of science or technology but because the
watchdog role is an integral part of journalism."
The Public
Is Not Ignorant Of Science
"After 15 years, the Royal Society is re-vamping Copus, its Committee
for the Public Understanding of Science and, unkind critics might
be heard to mutter, "None too soon". It has been a most intriguing
phenomenon in the sociology of science, showing how even the most well-meaning
and cleverest of people can be led astray by their own preconceptions,
and perpetrate nonsense."
Public
Strong On Opinions--Weaker On Knowledge
"The public's knowledge of topical science issues appears to be only
slightly improved by either their education or their consumption of news
media, according to interim findings from a research project at Cardiff
University, UK. However, lack of knowledge, where it exists, does not
prevent British people from holding opinions on subjects like climate
change, biotechnology and the alleged risks of the measles, mumps and
rubella (MMR) vaccine. Strong views are also held on their Government's
response to such questions."
The
Role Of Science In Making Good Decisions
"Mr. Chairman, members of the Committee, my name is Mark Frankel.
I head the Program on Scientific Freedom, Responsibility and Law in the Directorate for Science and Policy Programs
at the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). Founded
in 1848, AAAS is the worlds largest federation of scientific and
engineering societies, with nearly 300 affiliates. This year we are celebrating
our 150th anniversary. The Association supports the House Science Committees
undertaking of a National Science Policy Study and just last month submitted
a formal statement presenting its views on key issues to be addressed
in the development of a new science policy. (The May 1998 statement issued
by the AAAS Board of Directors is titled, A Framework for Federal Science
Policy, and can be found on the AAAS Web site at http://www.aaas.org/spp/fedsci.)
I welcome, therefore, this opportunity to testify before you today on
the role of science in informing legal and policy decisions that have
substantial scientific or technical components."
Science,
A Candle In The Dark
"The graduating students you see before you are very special and
very unique people. You know that they have worked hard, that they are
graduating from the premier university in the nation and from a campus
with 36 top-ranked departments, including our own as No. 1 in biology.
You know all those things. And you should be proud of your graduate. People
just like them, who graduated from Berkeley in years past, have significantly
changed the world. Some of your graduates will too. But I want to focus
on another reason why they are unique and special, and suggest a way that
they might change the world too. Your graduate has joined a tiny percentage
of Americans who are scientifically literate. He or she has become part
of that fewer than 5% of Americans who understand the process of science--how
it works. Maybe not all the facts, but how science is done and applied.
Fewer than 10 million other adults in the US know that. In fact, more
than 197 million adults have little idea how science works at all. In
just 20 years, those numbers will rise to 240 million illiterate and only
12.6 million literate in science. Worldwide, that will be over 5 billion,
400 million scientifically illiterate and a mere 285 million scientifically
literate people, more or less, in the year 2020."
Scientific Illiteracy
In The Press
"I'm the first to admit it: I have not made a scientific, double-
blind study of this phenomenon. I don't know whether this is really happening.
Perhaps it is just a crotchet of advancing age. But it appears to me that
the ignorance displayed by members of the press continually grows more
pronounced."
This
Is Science!
"Science is so exciting! Why? Because it is awe-inspiring, fun, and
creative. Most scientists would not do anything else--they are truly dedicated
to what they do. You can hardly get them to be quiet once they start talking
about their work. Unlike most people, they usually love their jobs! However,
this is not the common view of most scientists. They are commonly thought
of as nerds, freaks, weirdoes, or evil doers, but this is a movie or television
view. "
|